>>12The audience is the same.
The size of posts is all about typing effort, not quality.
Copypasta,in-jokes and memes are just a poor form of comedy.
Theres nothing serious about it, its more like r/linuxmemes instead of r/linux. And since the dominant content of /prog/ is terrible humor, which is almost everywhere it doesn't matter which thread you post on.
Moderation doesn't solve it, its all about the user culture:
reddit communities have related subreddits which contain
off-topic content or memes, just like any decent forum.
If there was /progmemes/ /progcode/ /progroleplay/ and /proghumor/ the userbase would focus on more specific content
categories. Instead /prog/ is cultural soup of different
groups with different interests, which alienates minority interest group from actively participating due being drowned
by meme/copypasta fanatics and political activists.
This creates a tense atmosphere where real discussion devolves into lowest denominator trash-talk. Quality or signal-to-noise drops with size and diversity of groups.
Stackoverflow deals with this by extreme moderation, while its
fairly easy to recategorize and move popular content where it
belongs. Seems to me /lounge/ serves more of generic chat, and
doesn't have much appeal to regulars of /prog/, so asking them to move to /lounge/ would be useless, since the content they produce deals with /prog/ issues and culture.